Carmella WWE NXT Women in WWE Professional wrestling, NAKED transparent background PNG clipart
In June 2017, Carmella became the winner of the inaugural women's . In April 2018, she became the first woman in WWE history to successfully cash-in her Money in the Bank opportunity, when she defeated to win the . In 2019, Carmella won both the and the . In November 2021, after being drafted to as part of the , Carmella formed an alliance with and the two went on to win the .
While continuing to Amore and Cassady, Carmella began with , which led to a match between the two on the August 26 episode of , which Carmella lost. In January 2016, Carmella won a to become the number one contender to 's . Carmella unsuccessfully challenged Bayley for the title on February 10. After the match, Eva Marie and attacked the two, which led to a on the February 24 episode of , which Carmella and Bayley lost. Carmella made her first appearance on WWE's main roster on March 12 at , accompanying Amore and Cassady for their match against for the NXT Tag Team Championship. On the May 25 episode of , Carmella competed in a against Alexa Bliss and Nia Jax to determine the number one contender to 's NXT Women's Championship at , but she was by Jax.
Carmella would team up with at to participate in a to determine the number one contenders against and for the , but were unsuccessful in the match. Carmella then faced both members of the Riott Squad individually, and beat them both. She then proclaimed herself "The Most Beautiful Woman in All of WWE". She would then have 3 opportunities for the SmackDown Women's Championship against Bianca Belair, one on the July 16 episode of SmackDown, one on the July 23 episode, and one at a house show in Louisville, Kentucky, but during all three of them, she would be unsuccessful in capturing the title. Carmella was then scheduled to be Sasha Banks' replacement for SummerSlam against Bianca Belair, but was then attacked by a returning Becky Lynch. Carmella lost to at the kickoff show.
On August 6th, Carmella suffered an injury during a . Carmella returned on the January 30, 2023, episode of , with her previous gimmick which she used until 2020. The following week on , Carmella defeated , , and in a to qualify for the women's Elimination Chamber match at the pay-per-view. At the event, Carmella failed to win the match after she was last pinned by Asuka. Following the March 13 episode of , Carmella went on hiatus from in-ring action due to her real-life pregnancy. On February 21, 2025, it was reported by that Carmella’s contract had expired and is no longer with WWE, ending her near twelve-year tenure with the company. Carmella had previously stated that she was recovering from post pregnancy complication, .
